The rainbow cake is a showstopper because of the reveal. Everything about making one is in service of that first slice.
Weigh your batter
This is the whole game. Make one large batch, weigh the total, divide by the number of layers, and portion by weight into separate bowls. Eyeballing gives you layers of different heights and a lopsided cake.
Six layers is traditional. Four reads as rainbow and is far easier to assemble and slice.
Color each portion
Mix deeper than your target, color mutes in the oven. Work in order so you can reuse the spatula from light to dark without cross-contaminating.
Use a concentrated color so the batter consistency stays identical across all six bowls. If one portion needed a lot more liquid to reach its shade, that layer bakes differently from the rest.
Bake thin and even
- Bake as many layers simultaneously as your oven allows
- Thin layers bake fast, start checking early
- Use cake strips or a damp towel band to reduce doming
- Rotate halfway for even color
Level everything
Domed layers stacked six high create a cone. Level each one flat. This is also what gives you those crisp horizontal stripes in the cut.
Assembly
- Thin, even frosting between layers, thick filling pushes layers apart and hides the stripes
- Chill after every two or three layers so the stack does not lean
- Crumb coat, then chill until firm
- Final coat in white for maximum contrast with the interior
The reveal
Keep the exterior plain. A white or very pale cake makes the interior land harder. A heavily decorated outside competes with the moment you are building toward.
Cut with a long, warm, clean knife and wipe between slices so colors do not drag.
Order of colors
Standard spectrum order, red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet, reads as a rainbow. Random order reads as a mistake.
Color With Confidence
Yeast Bakers is an Authorized Dealer for Colour Mill, so every bottle you buy from us is genuine stock. Shop the full Colour Mill oil blend range, free shipping on orders over $25.